Saturday, May 4, 2019

The Club - Meeting 296 - Dreams

The dreamers of the day are dangerous men, for they may act their dreams with open eyes, to make it possible.” ― T.E. Lawrence, Seven Pillars of Wisdom: A Triumph

Hello all.  Welcome back to the Disciplinary Couples Club.  Our weekly gathering of men and women who are in, or would like to be in, Domestic Discipline relationships.  I hope you had a good week.  In what is becoming a broken record, mine started strong on the behavior front, then ended in a big fail coupled with disobedience.

Well, last week’s topic sure . . . drifted.  We began with how sex has changed since DD and ended with whether religion frowns on dildo collections.  Seems like we all had a lot of time on our hands last week.

This week’s topic is only slightly less ethereal than our religious speculations.  I predict it won’t be nearly as lively a discussion, but it was the best I could come up with.  The topic is dreams related to spanking and domestic discipline.  For someone who spends as much time as I do thinking about domestic discipline and corporal punishment, I don’t tend to dream about such things very often.  Perhaps it’s because I am actually in a DD relationship, so I don’t need to dream about being in one?  Though, while I don’t have DD dreams very often, I do have them from time to time, and perhaps they reveal a bit about what drives me to do this thing we do.

I had an interesting one a couple of weeks ago. I had gotten into trouble for something; I’m not sure what but I think  it was some kind of low-level mischief.  In my dream, I was riding in a car with my mother.  In the dream, she was younger than she is today; probably mid- to late 40s.  She had picked me up from whatever trouble I had gotten into and was driving me home.  There was deep snow along the road.  She kept trying to pull off the road, but the car couldn’t make it far in the snow, so she would pull back onto the road, drive a little further, then try to pull over again. 



I asked her what she was doing, and she said something like, “I don’t think you understand the kind of trouble you could have gotten into back there, or how much you are in now.  So, I am going to take care of that.” It became very clear that she had been trying to pull off the road so she could spank me spank me in the car.  Fortunately or unfortunately depending on your perspective, I woke up before she could carry out that sentence.

A couple of months ago, I had a dream that probably speaks volumes about what I find really threatening.  I dreamed I was at a large gathering of business colleagues.  It may have been a holiday party or something like that.  But, unlike a normal work party, I also had family members in attendance, including both my wife and my father.  While the details are sketchy, someone had ordered me to be spanked for some office misbehavior.  It was to be done by our office manager, who is a man.  As he was attempting to take me to an adjacent room to spank me, I turned to my wife, who was sitting at a table with some other people from work.  I asked her to intercede.  I seemed to think there was something very unfair about the spanking, and I was very agitated and intent on pleading my case.  


Instead, she looked up from her conversation, and directed me very dismissively to run along and get it over with.  My father was sitting at a nearby table, and he too seemed fully on board with my forthcoming punishment.  He told me this one would be of a “totally different order” than anything I had experienced before. I was sullen and angry, though my concern seemed to be not so much the spanking itself but, rather, that everyone would know it was happening and might be able to overhear it.  Our manager took me out of the room, and in the odd manner of dreams I didn’t really experience the spanking from a first-person perspective, but I could hear myself getting spanked hard and crying.

 
Lots of interesting things going on there, and they all seem to speak to what I find very intimidating.  The office environment, where I definitely have been known to cause problems, and everyone there knowing what was about to happen to me.  My wife's casual and dismissive attitude, bordering on contemptuous.  The embarrassment of knowing others would hear me getting spanked.  And, being spanked by a man.   

So, how about you? Do you dream about spanking or discipline, whether giving or receiving?  If so, care to share a few dreams you have had, particularly anything that might be revealing about what drives you to be in this lifestyle?

Have a great week.

Saturday, April 27, 2019

The Club - Meeting 295 - Sex Since DD


Disobedience- that is the nobility of slaves. - Friedrich Nietzsche

Hello all.  Welcome back to the Disciplinary Couples Club.  Our weekly gathering of men and women who are in, or would like to be in, Domestic Discipline relationships.  I hope you had a good week.

Mine again started strong on the behavior front, then ended in a miserable fail that included open disobedience regarding an order she gave me before I left on a business trip.  I woke this morning dreading the weekend and its likely consequences, though I also know that I richly deserve whatever I have coming.  Damn.  Damn.  Damn.


 That was a good discussion last week, and it ended up hitting on a lot of big topics we’ve covered in the past, including crying and being “broken,” humiliation, humbling and embarrassment, and sex and sexuality in Domestic Discipline relationships. We'll cover some of those again soon. In discussing the last of them, Elizabeth suggested this topic: “How has your sex life changed since you began DD? Note that I ask "since," not "because of." So, in the time period since. There may be many other factors besides DD, and those should be addressed. But it would be difficult to say that DD is not a factor in any changes that have occurred. I would think that most couples have seen a change, even if DD has been throughout their relationship. As a teaser, I asked Frank for a one-sentence answer (on which he will elaborate if the question is chosen) and as I expected he said: "I have far fewer orgasms but a much better sex life."

Danielle responded, “I second Elizabeth's suggestion for having how couples' sex lives have changed since they began DD (or FLR). A sub-topic within that discussion could be one that Elizabeth raised in a response to last week's topic: how and to what extent husbands' access to pornography/erotica and their masturbation habits are managed by disciplinary wives. Inspired by Elizabeth, I asked Wayne to give a one sentence answer to the question about how sex has changed for him. His answer was: "Sex is more pervasive, more intense, and more spiritual in a FLR."

So, let’s make those the topics for this week, though I don’t have a lot to say about Elizabeth’s question.  I don’t think our sex life really has changed that much, whether as a result of Domestic Discipline or anything else.  Though, perhaps this thing we do has contributed to an underlying “erotic charge.”  She has perhaps gotten a little more "take charge," but not dramatically so.  But, the fact that I say our sex life hasn’t changed much in over a decade may indicate we need to do some work on that front.  We have a good sex life, but things can always be improved upon, right?  I do think that as we go deeper into FLR, our sexual dynamic is like to change as well.


As for access to pornography and masturbation, I don’t really have anything to contribute. Or, not much anyway.  She has never tried to restrict porn.  She did at one point make a rule around masturbation, but enforcement seemed to go by the wayside pretty quickly.  This week’s discussion could, of course, remind her about that one.

In addition to Elizabeth and Danielle’s suggestions, I want to ask a pointed question to our Disciplinary Wives:  Do you get turned on by doling out discipline?  If so, is there a particular aspect of it that excites you? 
 


I’m not sure whether my wife gets turned on by the spanking itself, but she has said that she likes ordering me to get ready for a spanking and watching me comply.  She also likes imposing corner time and watching me stand there, naked in the corner.  It seems clear that what she likes is the experience of telling me to comply and watching me do it.

Have a great week.

Saturday, April 20, 2019

The Club - Meeting #294 - Privileges & Their Removal


The ability to have a choice in what you do is a privilege.” - Anton Yelchin

Hello all.  Welcome back to the Disciplinary Couples Club.  Our weekly gathering of men and women who are in, or would like to be in, Domestic Discipline relationships.  I hope you had a good week. 

Like last week, mine started strong then degraded, once again based on my own inability to exercise self-control and moderation.  A couple of years ago, I read a book about habit formation.  It made the point that some people can reduce a “bad” behavior only incrementally.  If they want to diet, for example, they can’t just shut cut out all sugary desserts. They have to take it down incrementally.  Self-denial just doesn’t work for them. For others, it is the opposite.  Quitting a bad habit has to be cold turkey or nothing.  I suspect that in some areas, I fall into the latter camp.  I just can’t do moderation. 

We had a good discussion last week, though it’s notable how few of the comments really focused on implements. But, that’s OK.  Good conversations seldom follow a pre-planned course. Both Anna and Danielle commented that spanking is hardly the only way to discipline a misbehaving husband.  As Danielle observed, “Spanking is only one item in my disciplinary tool kit for Wayne, and I sometimes combine it with one of the following punishments: loss of privileges like watching sports or going golfing; loss or reduction of his monthly allowance; grounding; early bedtimes; temporary confiscation of his computer; temporary banishment from the marriage bed. I believe that all these things are humbling for a grown man.”

Danielle and I also talked about how some of the words we use to describe these restrictions and privileges are themselves inherently humbling, like “grounding” and “allowance.”  These are things that parents impose on children, and that’s part of why they can be disciplinary, right? They say, “you are acting like a little boy, so you get to be treated like one.”

We have experimented with grounding from time-to-time, though I think I use the term more broadly than some others do.  I apply it to any order that restricts my freedom of action, while I think others see it more narrowly as being physically confined to staying home and not engaging in social activities.  For us, “grounding” has almost always consisted of an order not to drink alcohol, and perhaps to be home from work at a particular time.   
 

Honestly, it hasn’t worked that well for one simple reason – I cheat and don’t always own up to that.  In a series of comments last week, I laid out the three factors that I think interact to make any disciplinary regime effective: (1) certainty of getting caught; (2) certainty of punishment; and (3) severity of punishment.  For us, grounding has never been effective because (1) and (2) are either missing or very inconsistent.  One major downside of my constant travel is she has no real way to ensure that I am complying with her directions.  And, even when she does know that I haven’t fully complied, she doesn’t always punish that misbehavior consistently.  So, while I am the one primarily at fault, she bears some responsibility, too.


 But, in theory, I think losing privileges and other non-corporal punishments could be effective as long as there was an adequate enforcement regime in place.  They check a lot of boxes: The punishment can be tailored to fit the crime. The punishment may last longer than a spanking, which is painful for a few minutes then done.  They may have a prophylactic component, nipping bad behavior in the bud before it begins.  And, for some men, not being able to hang out with friends or engage in some activities may be a lot harder punishment than a quick spanking.

How about you?  Do you use removal of privileges as a punishment? What form does that take? Has it been effective? For the men, how does being subjected to that kind of discipline or punishment make you feel? For the women, how does it feel to impose rules and consequences in that way? Is it harder for you than giving a spanking?  And, is the fact that it involves subjecting him to the kind of rules you might impose on your teenager something that heightens your own feelings of power? Does it inject a “maternal” element into managing your husband’s behavior, and is that good or bad?

Have a great week!

Saturday, April 13, 2019

The Club - Meeting 293 - Implements & Methods


“We shape our tools and afterwards our tools shape us.” - Marshall McLuhan

Hello all.  Welcome back to the Disciplinary Couples Club.  Our weekly gathering of men and women who are in, or would like to be in, Domestic Discipline relationships.  I hope you had a good week. 

Mine was kind of a wild ride.  Lots of travel.  Lots of downtime on planes, yet a lot of work accomplished, too.  I went into it with some pretty lofty behavioral goals and, unfortunately, I can’t say I met them.  Though, for once, things seemed to get better by the end of the week, with some real progress on some of the possible causes of the physical ailment I was dealing with. 

We had a pretty good discussion last week.  Thanks to Elizabeth and Frank for sharing the story of their disciplinary discussion with their brother-in-law and Elizabeth’s sister.  It sounds like it was not as embarrassing or demoralizing as Frank feared.  Perhaps a lesson for all of us in the possibility that our fears of the consequences of being more open are overblown?   

Also, a welcome to Danielle, another disciplinary wife, who left some comments near week-end, including some illuminating ones on the freedom inherent in “bitchiness.”

Now, on to this week’s topic.  Elizabeth suggested that I ask, “Which implement is most effective for you at changing behavior? Is it because it is the most painful, or are there other reasons? On the other hand, which implement is the least effective and why? And is there an implement you find particularly erotic?”

Tools are important. No doubt about that.  And, you certainly have to choose the right tool for the job.  I do believe that some of tools can be very effective, while some of those we associate most closely with Domestic Discipline are -- less so. 

I also believe, however, that the best spanking tool may fail to bring about real change if it isn't used diligently and consistently.  And, a "weak" tool can be effective if applied with enough effort and will. 

So, we will use Elizabeth's topic, though I want to expand it a little to include not just implements, but other DD practices and tools.  If the goal is to really change behavior, which implement or DD practice do you find most effective, and why?  Is it a particular implement, or some non-spanking tool such as lecturing, corner time, loss of privileges, etc.?
I will kick things off.  On the tool front, I really don’t know whether there is one that is more effective in bringing about actual change.  In fact, I don’t think there is, because I have  become convinced over time that changing behavior is, for me at least, more about consistency and duration.  I need the punishment for bad behavior to be certain and unavoidable, and the effectiveness of the spanking is more about how long it lasts than about the implement used.   

But, in terms of effectiveness, some tools will fool you.  We recently acquired an actual used DWC leather strap with holes, so short that it is almost like a paddle.  I used to think that leather paddles were too light to be effective, but something about this one really, really hurts.  It also tends to curl over my cheek and into the crack, which is excruciatingly painful.  
 Conversely, some tools we have dropped entirely because they are too extreme and actually defeated the disciplinary purpose. They either did too much damage or would cause me to go into “take it like a man mode,” because the pain was just too much to give in to.  Top of that category are heavy rubber straps.  

As for the most effective?  As I said above, I think duration is at least as important as the level of pain induced.  While a wooden paddle or bath brush can be incredibly painful, they also tend to numb my bottom fairly quickly.  Therefore, if I were forced to choose which tool has the most effective combination of severity and ability to go for a long time without damage or numbing, it is a heavy leather strap.





Least effective?  Ironically, it is probably the one I also find the most erotic – the hairbrush. But, one other tool that scores very high on eroticism but can also be quite effective is the  leather belt.  Of course, not all belts are created equal.  An effective one needs to be heavy, like leather “gun belts” for sportsmen and hunters. They are designed to bear the weight of sidearm.  I bought one about a year ago, and it can be very painful.  It also is one of the few tools that can be packed in a suitcase without risking unwanted snickers from TSA agents.  Belts are very erotic for me, though I also tend to think of them in terms of M/m spanking, probably because they were the implement of choice for most father's when I was growing up. Though, they were certainly wielded by some of the strict mothers as well.

But, if the issue is effectiveness in bringing about real behavioral change, I have come to conclude it isn’t a physical implement at all.  It is a combination of stern attitude and consistency.  The sternness and strictness can manifest in a lot of ways that do not have anything to do with spanking.  If she issues a blunt reprimand, that is effective.  Even more so was the time she made me apologize for bad workplace behavior to someone I really didn’t like.  Embarrassing me and humbling me in such ways—taking command, verbal strictness, using punishments that fit the crime—those seem to be much more effective at bringing about real behavioral change than the hardest spanking.

Alan also gave us a great example last week; one that includes both spanking and non-spanking elements.  Namely, a witness seeing him get spanked.  According to Alan, the prospect of being spanked in front of a witness, such as his wife's sister, is one the biggest deterrents to bad behavior.  Of course, it sounds like in his case a witnessed spanking is usually also a post-orgasm spanking, so one can understand the overall deterrent effect!

Similarly, Elizabeth requiring a conversation with Frank and his in-laws probably was a powerful tool for voicing her displeasure at the way he had been addressing her sister.

So, while behavior modification is only one goal of Domestic Discipline, which do you find most effective, least effective and most or least erotic?

Have a great week.

Saturday, April 6, 2019

The Club - Meeting 292 - First Time Asking


“A woman in love will do almost anything for a man, except give up the desire to improve him.” - Nathaniel Branden

Hello all.  Welcome back to the Disciplinary Couples Club.  Our weekly gathering of men and women who are in, or would like to be in, Domestic Discipline relationships.  I hope you had a good week.  Mine started off pretty well.  I felt like I was finally getting my feet under me in my new job role.  Then, it all deteriorated by week’s end.  But, I’ll take whatever progress I can get.  It’s, hopefully, a little like walking up a circular staircase; you come back to the same point over and over again but at a slightly higher elevation.  At least, that’s the hope.  I also developed a little physical ailment that may actually do a better job of slowing me down that Domestic Discipline has.  Getting old is not for wimps.

Last week’s topic on “others” knowing didn’t get a huge volume of response, though it did strike a chord for Elizabeth and Frank in light of the dynamic going on with her sister and brother-in-law. I am very interested in hearing about their upcoming discussion, if they care to share it with us. I am more than a little envious that Frank could end up with someone he can talk to face-to-face about this thing they do, with someone on the same side of the paddle.  As I’ve recounted, only three people really know about our DD relationship, and only two of those are in-person relationships.  Of those two, one isn’t into DD and the other is on the other end of the paddle.  That’s not nothing, but it would still feel freeing to have the comradery of someone else who has these same needs.

I’m a little distracted this weekend, so this topic will be a little short, and not one I have a lot to speak about directly.  It is an extension of the theme on “asking for it.”  Our earlier polls and most of our discussions verify that it is usually the husband who asks for the DD relationship.  It seems to be the same with most M/f dynamics – it is the disciplined spouse who initiates the relationship.   This week’s topic is pretty simple: Was there a specific event that lead you or your spouse to ask for it – “it” being the DD relationship as a whole?  Was there some particular bit of bad behavior that preceded asking for it that first time?  Or maybe some particular low point in personal behavior that drove wanting the accountability? Or, was there a point where a pre-existing fascination became overpowering?

My own story doesn’t really follow any of those lines.  I didn’t have a pre-existing fascination with adult discipline, and there wasn’t any behavior-related precipitating event.  I encountered the Disciplinary Wives Club website, and it caused a reaction that was strong, I really had to ask for it.  I suspect I did have some deep and previously unrecognized need for enforced accountability that was triggered by that website, but even though I like to think I am a fairly self-aware person, I did not recognize that need in myself until I found a website that expressed it so openly.

How about you? Tell us about the precipitating event that led you to ask or be asked be in a disciplinary relationship.  Or, if you are in that rare DD relationship that was imposed by the disciplinarian, tell us about that.

Saturday, March 30, 2019

The Club - Meeting 291 - Others


“A man who can't bear to share his habits is a man who needs to quit them.” ― Stephen King, The Dark Tower

Hello all.  Welcome back to the Disciplinary Couples Club.  Our weekly gathering of men and women who are in, or would like to be in, Domestic Discipline relationships.  I hope you had a good week.  We had a difficult one as a family.  I thought about skipping this week’s post, but I kind of needed the distraction.  Though, I also don’t have a lot of ambition or focus this weekend, so I’m going to simply play off of some of last week’s comments, using them to hearken back to a topic we did about a year ago.  But, we have added some participants since then . . .

Frank and I had a series of exchanges last week that began with observations on the eroticism of some spanking drawings involving Disciplinary Wives talking on telephones before or during a spanking. 

This seems to be a popular theme with spanking artists, though this is the only drawing I have found that involves the party who is going to be spanked, or just has been, doing the talking:



Then we talked a bit about others knowing about our Domestic Discipline relationship, but with the wrinkle that Frank knows his sister-in-law is the spanked party in some sort of spanking-oriented relationship, though not any of the details. While he doesn't know the details, his brother-in-law seems to be fairly open in displaying his authority and, perhaps, letting others know how he uses it?


 So, let's extend the discussion Frank and I had into this week's topic. As noted, it is one we have talked about before and, while some of our commenters have talked about this several times, others haven’t and the situation may have changed for even those who had commented about this on other posts.The topic is telling others about our Domestic Discipline or FLR relationships, and also what we know about others.  When we addressed this last time, it seemed like most of us (with a few exceptions, notably KD) are very skittish about letting others know either that we are spanked or that it is for disciplinary purposes, or both.  And, I do think those two—spanking and discipline—are separable with respect to what makes us reluctant to let others into our weird little worlds. The phenomenon of so many seemingly vanilla women openly reading the 50 Shades books would seem to indicate that the spanking kink side of DD is relatively well accepted, along with some light bondage.  I’m not sure the same is true about the reluctance to have others know that we are disciplined. 

As Frank and I discussed, there is something “edgy” about others knowing that I am a disciplined husband, even when I have chosen to tell them about it myself.  And, twice now (sort of three times), I have made that decision.  The first time, I chose to tell a female friend and work colleague who also is friends with Anne.  I don’t know exactly why I told her.  We were (and still are) close friends, and it was early in our Domestic Discipline and I think I felt some compulsion to share it with someone.  Maybe it was akin to the impulse that led me to blogging. The second time, I was approached by a female blogger who was the leader in an FLR relationship.  We talked anonymously for a long time before gaining sufficient trust to drop that anonymity.  In the ensuing couple of years, that relationship has gone in some unexpected directions, becoming intertwined with my professional life in some interesting and entertaining ways. Finally, there is one other person associated with this blog who now basically knows who I am or can figure it out pretty easily.

Now, even though I made the choice to open up with all three of these people and one of them was a close friend before I blabbed about our relationship to her, when I talk to the two with whom I have had live conversations, there definitely is some nervous energy that comes with them knowing about that side of me.  I don’t know whether “embarrassed” is the right word, but I am at least very aware when talking to them that they know that my wife is my boss and that she spanks my ass when she is unhappy with me.   

And, the fact that one of them does the same to her husband does not really change the “edginess” that comes with our shared secret.  Though, it’s not a bad sort of edginess, and I do still feel some odd desire to let even more people know about this aspect of myself.  Anne and I have been talking a lot lately about her being more openly dominant, and while I’m sure that if she starts doing that it will be embarrassing, I also think it will make me respect her and her power even more.

Though, work probably does remain the exception.  I work in a very conservative, traditional, and competitive profession.  I do think that in my particular field, there would be blowback if my status as a disciplined husband were widely known.  The thought of extended family knowing also causes me some angst. But, I'm still not sure why it is the combination of spanking plus the FLR aspect of our relationship that adds a special level of such angst.  And, I am less concerned about family knowing that I used to be, perhaps to some extent by learning of concrete examples, like a story KD has told about letting his mother know about this side of his relationship with Rosa.  http://mattmansfigures.homestead.com/momssupport.html

I will leave this topic fairly open-ended, but some things we could talk about include:

·      Who, if anyone, knows about your DD relationship, and how did they find out?
·      How did your relationship with, or feelings about, those to whom you have confided or who learned about your DD relationship change, if at all, after they found out?
·      Do you know about anyone else’s DD or FLR relationship?  How did you come to know about it?
·      Is there anyone you would like to tell about your DD relationship but have not?  What keeps you from telling them?
·      Do you think your spouse has or might tell someone about your relationship?  How would you feel about that?
·      For the Disciplinary Wives, if someone does know that you discipline your husband, how do they feel about that?  How does their knowledge make you feel?  Would you like to be more open about your own disciplinary status, i.e. that you “wear the pants” in the relationship and have the authority to punish your husband? 

I hope you all have a great week.

Saturday, March 23, 2019

The Club - Meetting 290 - Spanking in Anger and a Reprise on Asking For It

“Anybody can become angry - that is easy, but to be angry with the right person and to the right degree and at the right time and for the right purpose, and in the right way - that is not within everybody's power and is not easy.” – Aristotle

Hello all.  Welcome back to the Disciplinary Couples Club.  Our weekly gathering of men and women who are in, or would like to be in, Domestic Discipline relationships.  I hope you had a good week.

I am sorry for the later than usual posting, but it was one of those mornings.  Really, kind of one of those weeks. For once, I didn’t have much travel this week, though I had plenty of workplace activities.  It was another week in which I was productive, but to the point of not taking care of myself.  But, one of our kids is going to be around all weekend, and I have more work travel coming up next week.  So, I probably will not get punished; at least not in the next week. But, that is, to a big extent, my own fault.  We actually had some time alone at home on Thursday.  I was feeling a need for some enforced accountability, and I had planned to ask her to carry it out that night, reminding her that we likely would not have another opportunity.  I went up to our room a couple of times, while she was catching up on some paperwork for her job.  Since she was busy, I didn’t want to interrupt.  Or, that is what I told myself.  The plain fact is, it was really that conundrum of needing a hard spanking but not wanting it once the reality was staring me in the face.

Coincidentally, over the weekend I read a series of spanking stories entitled The Sinclair Method, https://voiceinthecorner.com/2014/03/07/the-sinclair-method/, after reading about it on The Venus & Cupid blog.  In one installment, one of the young women who are being trained to be more disciplined receives repeated spankings, all because she repeatedly fails to present herself and ask for it after she has been sentenced to one.  While this was a F/f series of spanking stories, there were themes that resonated with me, including learning to submit to someone else’s orders and authority, surrender, and the humbling of being required to be an active participant in your own spanking, including being forced to present yourself for it when you are ready.  The fact that “asking for it” resonated with me is a little paradoxical, and we’ve had exchanges here in which many of us have talked about how we want forced boundaries or consequences, and it is hard for it to feel forced when you are driving the process.  Yet, I think there is a relevant distinction here.  In the stories, the governess or trainer had already ordered the spanking, and also ordered the recipient to present herself, brush in hand that evening.  So, the disciplinarian remained very much in control, and part of exercising that control was forcing the recipient to spend some time anticipating the spanking to come and then screw up the courage to come upstairs, present herself for the spanking and ask for it humbly and contritely.  A few months ago, I did something kind of like that.  I had done something that didn’t really violate any rule, but that made me feel like I deserved to be punished for not stepping up on something I wanted to do.  I came to her, with paddle in hand, and asked her to spank me.  She did so, but only after telling me that she was working on something and that I should sit on the ottoman at the foot of the bed, back to her as she worked, until she was ready.  It was very humbling, and that spanking remains in my thoughts many weeks later. 

The bottom line is, I think I need to ask her to implement something like the stories, such that after she has ordered a spanking or I have reported on behavior that deserves one, I have to present myself when I am ready and ask her for one.  She can then decide whether to do it at that time, or keep me waiting longer. 

While everyone should feel free to talk about the above, it’s not the primary topic this week.  Instead, I want to extend the discussion about the wives’ demeanor during a spanking, from a particular angle.  Elizabeth and Frank talked about how she lectures and disciplines with a smile on her face, and it clearly works for them.  At the under end of the spectrum, I prefer it when my wife is all business and very strict verbally and in terms of her “no nonsense” demeanor.  ZM was somewhere in the middle, liking his wife’s nice, sweet side when discipline was not in play but wanting her to be more strict and tough in the DD context.

Right now, when my wife lectures before a spanking, it tends to be a bit like this:


 But, I feel I need it be more like this:



Why? Because the second has a better chance of humbling me and making me really surrender emotionally to what is about to happen. And, personally, I like it when my wife displays emotion before or during a spanking.  I think it is part of her learning to express her emotions and gain the confidence to say what she means.  I want her to know that it is OK to hurt not just my bottom but my feelings, because it may be that the reason I am bent over getting by bottom strapped or paddled is because I hurt hers.  Also, my ego is pretty strong, and I need more than just a cold, clinical application of the paddle to break down my defenses and really accept accountability. It also helps me to accept her authority if she is expressing herself like she really is in charge. I talked last week about how we are making some progress in her exercising more daily control, tightening the boundaries and keeping me in line.  I think the more she expresses her anger, the more those lines and boundaries are going to be authentic and real and, yes, maybe a bit non-consensual.

There is also this, which I think reflects an approach that is stern, if not particularly expressive:

 

Or this, in which the maternal figure seems to be letting him have it verbally in a way that is bringing about some real contrition.  As a metaphor for bringing out the contrite boy who knows he deserves what he is about to get, I like this one.

A few weeks ago, Tomy referenced times when Aunt Kay would spank in anger, and how those definitely created a very distinct impression, saying "She was very practical and a real mother bear. So discipline was simply "done when required." The times I got it when she was really angry were - extremely memorable."  I hope he will take this opportunity to tell us more about those times.  

How about you? Do you want your wife to express whatever anger she feels at your behavior?  Disciplinary Wives, does DD help you express your anger or disappointment more openly, or do you feel like that is something you need to control or suppress?

Saturday, March 16, 2019

The Club - Meeting 289 - Verbal Strictness

"Know what? Bitches get stuff done.” – Tina Fey

Hello all.  Welcome back to the Disciplinary Couples Club.  Our weekly gathering of men and women who are in, or would like to be in, Domestic Discipline relationships.  I hope you had a good week.

Mine was nutty and harried and hard from start to finish.  I actually thought that things might wind down a bit as I got to Friday. Nope.  Things went from bad to worse thanks to an unexpected personnel issue that will now make my professional life even harder than it already was.  That was the state I was in when I got back home last night after a flight.  Burned out, frustrated, tired.  We went out to dinner and ran into another couple we know well, which was great though it led to some excessive drinking on my part.  My mind and body were still running on overdrive when we got home, and I was pretty tempted to spend some time either watching a movie or surfing the Net, or both.  But, Anne was having none of it.  She ordered me to turn off the computer and get ready for bed.  I was very resentful at the time, because that is how I react to being ordered around. But, it undoubtedly saved me from feeling even more tired and draggy this morning.

That all leads me into this week’s topic, which came to me after last night’s events and after catching up on some of the comments from last week.  You all carried on a great conversation without me, and I particularly liked the exploration of the relationship between self-discipline and discipline that is imposed externally, whether by a strong Disciplinary Wife or by a military drill sergeant.  I can understand Elizabeth’s concern about whether external discipline might actually become a crutch that inhibits the formation of self-discipline, but I think Alan really hits the nail on the head in observing that is it not a single spanking or sporadic discipline that helps those of us who lack internal regulators.  Instead, it is something that builds up over time, with consistency being the key.  

I also do think that if the goal is to modify certain behaviors, then it may not really matter whether the discipline comes from within or from without, as long as it gets the job done.  The military model is also interesting in that the drill sergeant has a lot of limits placed on him in terms of physical punishment.  The days of being literally whipped into shape are a thing of the past in today’s army and navy.  So, a lot of the discipline comes through strong verbal guidance and direction.  The military’s leaders express their dominance through strict discipline conveyed through strongly-worded verbal commands that convey their authority in such a strict and intimidating way that resistance is rare.  Another aspect of military training that dovetails with some of the things ZM and I were talking about regarding performing under challenging circumstances that in many cases those being trained are not, in fact, undisciplined.  Think of the SEALs.  Most of them are experienced operators before they undertake SEAL training, yet most of them scrub out of that program.  It just requires a completely different level of performance.  In those circumstances, the role of the trainers is to help those who can bust through their own self-limiting beliefs, pushing through those plateaus to reach a whole new level of performance they didn't even know they had in them.

I was thinking about all that in relation to Anne’s direction last night.  She was firm and resolute and made it clear that she was not backing down just because I was resistant and wanted to stay up later.  I have talked a lot about my need for externally imposed boundaries. Each of those three words are important.  If I had the ability to impose boundaries on myself, I would.  Since I don’t on a regular basis, I need the application of some external force to move me back onto the path.  And, because I am relative headstrong, the force has to be imposed.  If I ask for it or direct the process, then it isn’t really being imposed on me.  And, the boundary actually needs to be real.  It can’t be something that she adjusts every time I test it.  It needs to be me who yields, not her or the boundary she set.

What we are really talking about is strictness.  Setting a rule and making it stick.  Setting a standard and invoking real consequences if it isn’t met.  I didn’t have much of that growing up, which I suspect is why I crave it now.  And, I increasingly think it is that verbal strictness that I really want deep down inside.  I’ve run polls on the blog a couple of times regarding whether disciplined men want “more” or “less” of certain things in the relationship.  More or fewer spankings? Harder spankings, or less so? More rules or fewer?  There was a strong tilt toward more on every factor.  But, there was only one where 100% of respondents said they wanted more – verbal strictness.  Every single man who answered the poll (76 of them) said he wanted his wife to be more verbally strict.

Do I want that?  Much like being spanked, it is very dependent on timing.  I certainly don’t like or want it when it is happening.  Like last night.  Did I like her making me go to bed on time, like a teenager with a curfew?  Absolutely not.  I resented the hell out of it.  Not really because I resented her control in and of itself, but because I really wanted to stay up and decompress more from the bad week, and she was saying I was not going to be allowed to do that.  She set the boundary, and it was a real one as evidenced by the fact that as soon as I bumped up against it I resisted and resisted and hated that I had to stay within the bounds.  But, this morning I recognize it was, in fact, for my own good, and I appreciate her for being strict and unyielding with me last night.

For the men, do you want your wife to be more verbally strict?  Do you respond to the drill sergeant approach?  For the women, is being very commanding verbally something you are comfortable with?  I think this, more than any other aspect of DD, is where the deeply entrenched female concerns about “bitchiness” come into play.  I dug up a couple of comments on this from some old posts.  First, a perspective from one of the husbands:

“I did perceive my wife as bitchy, BEFORE we agreed on a DD program to correct things that I did that angered her. Truthfully, I agreed she had good cause for concluding I was a pain in the ass on some occasions. We listed those things and I gave her enforcement powers to paddle me as she felt I deserved when one of our agreements was violated. It didn't take long for her to really buy into enforcing that agreement. Nor did it take me long to eliminate troubling behaviors because the paddlings I got were painful enough to be avoided. But most importantly I know the rules, my wife is not bitchy (she is proactive at solving issues that were causing problems in our marriage) and I appreciate that because it solves the issue quickly. I would much rather have my wife paddle my behind good and hard than to listen to her bitching or giving me the silent treatment.”

Now a couple from the wives.  This one from Holly:

“I think we are all "bitches" to our husbands when the rubber hits the road (so to speak.) I reconciled myself to this long ago. The amusing thing is that growing up I thought my mother was a bitch for spanking too often and too severely. Now I find although I probably do not spank as often as she did, I certainly spank harder. If a wife wants results, she does need to be a “bitch” sometimes.  As Tina Fey said: " Bitches get stuff done.” I am not saying that being a bitch is necessary to be a good disciplinarian. But, sometimes being a bitch is just what is needed and don't be intimidated by the fact that someone (like your husband) might think you are a bitch once in a while.”

And, this one from my good friend Rhiannon, whose blog I have a link to:

“It must be difficult in many ways to be a submissive male, but it is also difficult to be a Mistress or a Female leader.  Retraining my mind so I don’t feel like I am just adding more to his plate or being a bitch is hard.  It is also hard to make the choices. To really think about being in charge, the impact my actions have on my husband and to strive with everything to make the best decisions I can.  But, it also is hard not to make the choices, and things go more smoothly for both of us the longer I stay in this new role.  And, in the end, it is so worth it.”

Let us know your thoughts on all this.  I hope you have a great week.